Comparing the Production of Ohio State's Wide Receivers in the Urban Meyer Era to Those at Indiana Under Kevin Wilson

By Eric Seger on February 19, 2017 at 7:45 am
A look at how the production of Ohio State's wide receivers under Urban Meyer compare to that of Kevin Wilson's at Indiana.
Former Hoosier Ricky Jones Jr.
61 Comments

There is at least one thing Kevin Wilson's Indiana football teams had that Urban Meyer's Ohio State ones have not yet achieved: A 1,000-yard performer at wide receiver.

The Buckeye that came closest to that number in Meyer's first five seasons was Devin Smith, who racked up 931 yards during the 15-game 2014 national championship season. Arguably the best deep threat to make his way through the program, Smith reached that total on just 33 receptions. The staggering 28.2 yards per catch average easily led the country.

In his six seasons in Bloomington, Wilson's offense yielded a 1,000-yard receiver twice: first in 2013 when Cody Latimer caught 72 passes for 1,096 yards and two seasons ago when Simmie Cobbs Jr. reeled in 60 balls for 1,035 yards. This past season, Nick Westbrook came extremely close to pushing his receiving total to four digits: he led the Hoosiers with 995 yards on 54 receptions.

Meyer and Wilson's offenses are not the same but operate under similar spread principles. Ohio State focuses more on the power running game, using a mobile quarterback on the ground as an advantage while operating behind a running back that blocks well. When Wilson coached Indiana, he didn't rely as heavily on the quarterback run to move the sticks on the ground. His plan used more finesse at running back and a zone-blocking scheme.

Both programs essentially threw the ball the same amount, at least in relevance to the score of the game. For example, teams often throw it more if they are trailing. Indiana trailed in more games under Wilson than Ohio State has under Meyer.

So as we continue to dive into what the 2017 version of Meyer's offense will look like at Ohio State, it is prudent to peek back at how Wilson used his wide receivers. We do that below, hoping to show that Wilson's offenses used more with less at the position. Each player listed is a wide receiver unless otherwise noted. Only players that finished with at least 100 yards receiving each season are included.

2011

Indiana Record: 1-11, 0-8 Big Ten
*Note: This season is included to illustrate the talent Wilson inherited in his first season. We did not show Ohio State's 2011 receiving totals because Luke Fickell was the head coach, not Meyer.

PLAYER, AGE 247 RANKING G REC YDS AVG TD NFL CAREER?
Kofi Hughes, SO 3-Star 12 35 536 15.3 3 Undrafted in 2014, last with Bears that year
Damarlo Belcher, SR N/A 6 25 286 11.4 1 No; dismissed from program in Nov. 2011, later arrested
Jamonne Chester, SO 3-Star 10 21 240 11.4 0 No
Dre Muhammad, SR N/A 12 26 238 9.1 0 Undrafted in 2012, signed camp contract with Raiders, cut
Duwyce Wilson, SO 3-Star 8 17 217 12.8 3 No
Shane Wynn, FR 4-Star 12 19 197 10.4 0 Undrafted in 2015, currently with Jaguars
Ted Bolser, SO (TE) 3-Star 12 14 165 11.8 1 7th round pick of Redskins in 2014, out of NFL by 2015
Stephen Houston, SO (RB) 3-Star 12 17 164 9.6 0 Undrafted in 2014, on Ravens practice squad in 2016
Cody Latimer, FR 3-Star 8 12 141 11.7 2 2nd round pick of Broncos in 2014, 16 career catches

2012

Indiana Record: 4-8, 2-6 Big Ten

PLAYER, AGE 247 RANKING G REC YDS AVG TD NFL CAREER?
Cody Latimer, SO 3-Star 12 51 805 15.8 6 See above
Shane Wynn, SO 4-Star 12 67 648 9.7 6 See above
Kofi Hughes, JR 3-Star 11 43 639 14.9 3 See above
Ted Bolser, JR (TE) 3-Star 12 41 445 10.8 3 See above
Stephen Houston, JR (RB) 3-Star 12 37 381 10.3 4 See above
Duwyce Wilson, JR 3-Star 12 23 230 10.0 1 See above
D'Angelo Roberts, SO (RB) 3-Star 12 15 152 10.1 0 No
Jamonne Chester, JR 3-Star 12 17 132 7.8 0 See above
Nick Stoner, SO 3-Star 12 13 118 9.1 0 No

Ohio State Record: 12-0, 8-0 Big Ten

PLAYER, AGE 247 RANKING G REC YDS AVG TD NFL CAREER?
Philly Brown, JR 4-Star 12 60 669 11.1 3 Undrafted in 2014, signed with Panthers, 79 career catches
Devin Smith, SO 3-Star 12 30 618 20.6 6 2nd round pick by Jets in 2015, 10 career catches
Jake Stoneburner, SR (TE/WR) 4-Star 12 16 269 16.8 4 Undrafted in 2013, signed with Packers, now with Saints, 5 career catches
Evan Spencer, SO 4-Star 12 12 136 11.3 0 6th round pick by Redskins in 2015, out of league
Nick Vannett, FR (TE) 4-Star 12 9 123 13.7 0 3rd round pick by Seattle in 2016, 3 catches as rookie

 Ohio State also had four players catch a touchdown pass in 2012 that are not listed: tight end Jeff Heuerman, receiver Chris Fields and running backs Rod Smith and Carlos Hyde.

2013

Indiana Record: 5-7, 3-5 Big Ten

PLAYER, AGE 247 RANKING G REC YDS AVG TD NFL CAREER?
Cody Latimer, JR 3-Star 12 72 1,096 15.2 9 See above
Kofi Hughes, SR 3-Star 12 47 739 15.7 7 See above
Shane Wynn, JR 4-Star 12 46 633 13.8 11 See above
Ted Bolser, SR (TE) 3-Star 12 35 320 9.1 6 See above
Nick Stoner, JR 3-Star 12 12 226 18.8 1 See above
Tevin Coleman, SO (RB) 3-Star 9 19 193 10.1 0 3rd round pick of Falcons in 2015, integral part of Atlanta offense
Duwyce Wilson, SR 3-Star 12 15 167 11.1 0 See above
Isaiah Roundtree, JR N/A 12 14 136 9.7 1 No
Stephen Houston, SR (RB) 3-Star 12 11 113 10.3 0 See above

Ohio State Record: 12-2, 8-0 Big Ten, Lost to Clemson 40-35 in Orange Bowl

PLAYER, AGE 247 RANKING G REC YDS AVG TD NFL CAREER?
Philly Brown, SR 4-Star 14 63 771 12.2 10 See above
Devin Smith, JR 3-Star 14 44 660 15.0 8 See above
Jeff Heuerman, JR (TE) 3-Star 14 26 466 17.9 4 3rd round pick of Broncos in 2015, nine career catches
Evan Spencer, JR 4-Star 14 22 216 9.8 3 See above
Dontre Wilson, FR (RB/WR) 4-Star 14 22 210 9.5 2 2017 NFL Draft hopeful
Chris Fields, SR 3-Star 12 16 193 12.1 6 No
Carlos Hyde, SR (RB) 4-Star 12 16 147 9.2 3 2nd round pick of 49ers in 2015, team's No. 1 running back

2014

Indiana Record: 4-8, 1-7 Big Ten

PLAYER, AGE 247 RANKING G REC YDS AVG TD NFL CAREER?
Shane Wynn, SR 3-Star 12 56 708 12.6 3 See above
Nick Stoner, SR 3-Star 9 22 217 9.9 1 See above
J-Shun Harris II, FR 2-Star 12 18 168 9.3 2 No
Tevin Coleman, JR (RB) 3-Star 12 25 141 5.6 0 See above
Simmie Cobbs Jr., FR 3-Star 11 7 114 16.3 0 Still in school

Ohio State Record: 14-1, 8-0 Big Ten, Beat Alabama 42-35 and Oregon 42-20 to win College Football Playoff National Championship

PLAYER, AGE 247 RANKING G REC YDS AVG TD NFL CAREER?
Devin Smith, SR 3-Star 15 33 931 28.2 12 See above
Michael Thomas, SO 3-Star 15 54 799 14.8 9 2nd round pick of Saints in 2016, put together best rookie receiving season since Randy Moss
Jalin Marshall, FR (RB/WR) 4-Star 15 38 499 13.1 6 Undrafted in 2016, signed with Jets, 14 catches as rookie
Dontre Wilson, SO (RB/WR) 4-Star 10 21 300 14.3 3 See above
Corey Smith, JR 4-Star 14 20 255 12.7 0 2017 NFL Draft hopeful
Nick Vannett, JR (TE) 4-Star 14 19 220 11.6 5 See above
Ezekiel Elliott, SO (RB) 4-Star 15 28 220 7.9 0 1st round pick of Cowboys in 2016, led NFL in rushing as rookie
Jeff Heuerman, SR (TE) 3-Star 14 17 207 12.2 2 See above
Evan Spencer, SR 4-Star 15 15 149 9.9 3 See above

2015

Indiana Record: 6-7, 2-6 Big Ten, Lost to Duke 44-41 in Pinstripe Bowl

PLAYER, AGE 247 RANKING G REC YDS AVG TD NFL CAREER?
Simmie Cobbs Jr., SO 3-Star 13 60 1,035 17.2 4 See above
Ricky Jones, JR 2-Star 13 54 906 16.8 5 2017 NFL Draft hopeful
Mitchell Paige, JR Walk-on 13 57 684 12.0 6 2017 NFL Draft hopeful
Michael Cooper, SR (TE) 3-Star 13 17 205 12.0 2 Undrafted in 2016, signed with Redskins then Steelers, free agent
Andre Booker, SR N/A 11 9 198 22.0 3 No
Anthony Corsaro, SR (TE) 2-Star 12 10 142 14.2 0 No
Jordan Howard, JR (RB) 2-Star 9 11 106 9.6 1 5th round pick of Bears in 2016, became starter and made Pro Bowl
Damon Graham, SR N/A 13 10 102 10.2 0 No

Ohio State Record: 12-1, Beat Notre Dame 44-28 in Fiesta Bowl

PLAYER, AGE 247 RANKING G REC YDS AVG TD NFL CAREER?
Michael Thomas, JR 3-Star 13 56 781 13.9 9 See above
Jalin Marshall, SO (RB/WR) 4-Star 12 36 477 13.2 5 See above
Braxton Miller, SR (RB/WR) 5-Star (QB) 13 26 341 13.1 3 3rd round pick of Texans in 2016, caught 15 passes as a rookie
Curtis Samuel, SO (RB/WR) 4-Star 13 22 289 13.1 2 Left school early for 2017 NFL Draft
Ezekiel Elliott, JR (RB) 4-Star 13 27 206 7.6 0 See above
Nick Vannett, SR (TE) 3-Star 13 19 162 8.5 0 See above

2016

Indiana Record: 6-7, 4-5 Big Ten, Lost to Utah 26-24 in Foster Farms Bowl (Wilson did not coach bowl)

PLAYER, AGE 247 RANKING G REC YDS AVG TD NFL CAREER?
Nick Westbrook, SO 3-Star 13 54 995 18.4 6 Still in school
Ricky Jones, SR 2-Star 13 53 848 16.0 3 See above
Mitchell Paige, SR Walk-on 13 58 646 11.1 4 See above
Luke Timian, SO N/A 13 19 277 14.6 2 Still in school
Donavan Hale, SO 3-Star 12 13 210 16.1 1 Still in school
Camion Patrick, JR 3-Star 9 6 154 25.7 1 Still in school
Devine Redding, JR (RB) 3-Star 13 27 146 5.4 2 Still in school
PLAYER, AGE 247 RANKING G REC YDS AVG TD NFL CAREER?
Curtis Samuel, JR (RB/WR) 4-Star 13 74 865 11.7 7 See above
Noah Brown, SO 4-Star 13 32 402 12.6 7 Left school early for 2017 NFL Draft
Dontre Wilson, SR (RB/WR) 4-Star 12 27 352 13.0 5 See above
Marcus Baugh, JR (TE) 4-Star 13 24 269 11.2 2 Still in school
K.J. Hill, FR 4-Star 11 18 262 14.6 1 Still in school
Parris Campbell, SO 4-Star 13 13 121 9.3 0 Still in school
Terry McLaurin, SO 4-Star 13 11 114 10.4 2 Still in school

On one hand, the tables above are simply a bunch of names and numbers. But on the other, it is evident that Wilson — fairly consistently — has gotten more production out of his wide receivers than Meyer. There are plenty of factors that play into why.

Specifically, in 2014 and 2015 workhorse running back Ezekiel Elliott demanded carries and represented the type of back Meyer adores to use in his offense. Wilson ran the ball more too when he had a similar talent — the numbers of Indiana's wide receivers in 2014 were easily the worst in his tenure other than his first year on the job. Current NFL running back Tevin Coleman ran for more than 2,000 yards that season. That affected the passing numbers.

Wilson's use of tempo on offense helps get more plays — read: opportunities — for his receivers to make plays on the outside. The strength of each team's defense must also be taken into account. That side of the ball has been terrific for Ohio State the last three seasons. It was never anything to write home about for Wilson at Indiana.

When teams can't stop anybody, they have to try and win games by scoring as many points as possible. That usually translated into passing more for Wilson with quarterbacks Nate Sudfeld and most recently, Richard Lagow.

Yes, Meyer loves to establish a dominant running game so he can set up the play action downfield pass. He demands offensive balance and always says the goal is 250 yards passing and 250 yards rushing. The Buckeyes got away from that the last two seasons, which resulted in the change of the offensive staff and hiring of Wilson in addition to new quarterbacks coach Ryan Day.

The back-and-forth at quarterback in 2015 didn't help Ohio State's passing game, either. Meyer alternated Cardale Jones and J.T. Barrett well into October before settling on the latter. Then Barrett got arrested and cited for OVI on Halloween and was subsequently suspended for a game. The end result was the best rookie receiver in the NFL this season (Michael Thomas) being criminally underused and not even catching 60 passes in 13 games.

The potential for what Wilson can do with more talent understandably excites the Ohio State fanbase. His highest-rated recruit at wide receiver during his stint at Indiana was 4-star Shane Wynn from Cleveland. The Buckeyes routinely pull in 4-star receivers and signed three tall, fast and long players at the position in 2017 (Trevon Grimes, Jaylen Harris and Elijah Harris).

Ohio State's passing game desperately needed a facelift. Wilson's arrival and some better performance from Zach Smith's unit should yield better production in the passing game from the wide receivers. That is how it looks on paper, anyway.

61 Comments
View 61 Comments