College Sports Forum

College Sports Forum

College sports fan talk.

F+ Ratios of 1st Round Matchups

+8 HS
Brutus's Hat's picture
December 10, 2024 at 1:41pm
21 Comments

I took the F+ Rankings for each offense and defense and took the ratio of the opponents opposing side for each game.

A ratio 100% means you should expect that team to struggle to score, and > 100% means easier scoring.
 

Team 1 Team 2 Team 1 Scoring Ratio Team 2 Scoring Ratio Difference
Ohio State Tennessee 91% 39% 52%
Notre Dame Indiana 124% 84% 40%
Penn State SMU 141% 86% 55%
Texas Clemson 132% 59% 73%

Looks like it would predict a lower scoring game than usual given both teams having strong defenses compared to the opposing team's offense. 

Tennessee's offense (#25), however is abysmal compared to a top 2 defense from OSU. Only ASU's offense is worse. Their defense has a favorable matchup against our offense but not by much.

I'm surprised that Indiana isn't so badly outmatched by Notre Dame. Indiana's #4 offense is held in check by Notre Dame's #3 defense. But their defense (#15) is only a bit behind Notre Dame's offense (#7).

Noting too surprising in the other games given how weak the opponents are.

Assuming chalk we would get the following:
 

Team 1 Team 2 1 Offense Adv. 2 Offense Adv. Difference
Oregon Ohio State 100% 121% -21%
Georgia Notre Dame 80% 114% -34%
ASU Texas 53% 169% -116%
Boise PSU 89% 286% -197%

This model is predicting the opposite of chalk - every bye team loses. Oregon/OSU and Georgia/ND are close but the rest are not at all (not surprising).

Following the model we get:

 
 

Team 1 Team 2 1 Off Adv 2 Off Adv Diff
Texas Ohio State 59% 76% -17%
ND PSU 103% 82% 21%

OSU vs. Notre Dame for the finals:
 

    ND O OSU O Diff
ND OSU 72% 85% 13%

OSU wins the title in this one.

Not surprising since OSU is F+ overall #1, but has to go through #2, #3, #4, and #10 teams to get there.

This is a forum post from a site member. It does not represent the views of Eleven Warriors unless otherwise noted.

View 21 Comments