Love Cardale and he picked some good ones but there’s a bit of recency bias here. 

QB: CJ Stroud

RB: Zeke Elliott

WR1: Ted Ginn Jr.

WR2: Garrett Wilson

WR3: Michael Thomas

TE: Marcus Baugh 

I think at OSU it’s incredibly hard to pick a list like this due to being dominant forever.  Heck it’s tough even to do it by 20 year eras:  Best of the 2000s, best of the 80s & 90s, Best of the 70s & 80s, etc.

So, for my first list, I’m sticking with the 2000s. 
 

QB: CJ Stroud

RB: Zeke

WR1: Garrett Wilson

WR2: Marvin Harrison Jr.

WR3: Teddy Ginn Jr.

TE: Cade Stover

This is tough and I can already disagree with myself.  WR is enormously difficult.
Still, I’m sure a team that started these guys would be virtually unstoppable.

What are your lists?