Freshman Tracker: Carnell Tate Burns His Redshirt and Malik Hartford and Jermaine Mathews Jr. Play Their Fourth Game in Ohio State’s Win over Maryland

By Matt Gutridge on October 8, 2023 at 3:30 pm
Carnell Tate
9 Comments

Facing undefeated Maryland, a program Ohio State has always defeated, one could have reasonably expected a slew of freshmen to get playing time against Mike Locksley's team.

A slow start and an early 10-0 hole for Ohio State prevented the young Buckeyes from gaining valuable game experience. Malik Hartford, Brandon Inniss, Jermaine Mathews Jr. and Carnell Tate were the only true freshmen to see the field. 

Tate caught the one pass for eight yards and helped on the kickoff, kickoff return and punt return teams. The IMG Academy alum is the only member of the 2023 class to play in every game this season. He’s also the first to use up his redshirt eligibility. 

Hartford helped on every punt return team, while Mathews played on the kickoff coverage and punt return teams. Inniss was on the field for the four kickoff returns. Hartford, Inniss, Mathews and Luke Montgomery are each one game appearance away from losing their redshirts.

(Editing note: C.J. Hicks and Brandon Inniss both wear No. 11. We received confirmation that both Inniss and Hicks were on the kickoff return team. Inniss was wearing No. 11 and Hicks sported No. 16. The article has been updated to include Inniss.)

Next week, the Buckeyes head to West Lafayette to take on two-win Purdue. With Ohio State's sketchy history in Ross-Ade Stadium and this team's penchant for slow starts, it is not a guarantee the freshmen will see extended playing time there either.

% of Freshmen Who Played in First Five Games
SEASON PERCENTAGE
2023 10-21 (0.476)
2022 17-21 (0.810)
2021 18-23 (0.783)
2020 17-25 (0.680)
2019 13-17 (0.765)
2018 20-25 (0.800)

So far this season, less than half of Ohio State’s scholarship freshmen have seen playing time in any game, by far the fewest through five games since the NCAA changed the redshirt rule in 2018 to allow players to participate in up to four games and still redshirt. By comparison, 81 percent of Ohio State’s scholarship freshmen appeared in at least one of the Buckeyes’ first five games last year. Only 68 percent of Ohio State’s scholarship freshmen saw action in the first five games of 2020, but the Buckeyes played only five regular-season games that year due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Through five games, only 10 of Ohio State's 21 scholarship true freshmen have seen the field.

Class of 2023 Tracker
NAME POS DEBUT MARYLAND STATS GP SEASON STATS
CARNELL TATE WR Indiana 1 catch, 8 yards 5 5 catches, 83 yards, 1 TD
MALIK HARTFORD S Indiana Special teams 4 3 tackles, 1 PBU
JERMAINE MATHEWS JR. CB Indiana Special teams 4 2 tackles, 1 INT, 1 PBU, 1 TD
BRANDON INNISS WR Indiana Special teams 4 4 offensive snaps
LUKE MONTGOMERY OL Indiana   4 20 offensive snaps
ARVELL REESE LB Indiana   2 Special teams
NOAH ROGERS WR Indiana   2 8 offensive snaps
KAYDEN McDONALD DL WKU   1 4 defensive snaps
JASON MOORE DL WKU   1 3 defensive snaps
JELANI THURMAN TE WKU   1 5 offensive snaps
JAYDEN BONSU S        
NIGEL GLOVER LB        
CEDRICK HAWKINS S        
LINCOLN KIENHOLZ QB        
JOSHUA MICKENS DE        
JOSHUA PADILLA OL        
BRYSON RODGERS WR        
AUSTIN SIEREVELD OL        
CALVIN SIMPSON-HUNT CB        
WILL SMITH JR. DT        
MILES WALKER OT        

(Note: The table does not include freshman walk-ons who have not yet played.)

9 Comments
View 9 Comments